Movie Review: Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011)

You know, when talk of a Pirates of the Caribbean 4 started not long after the release of Pirates of the Caribbean 3, I didn’t think it was actually going to happen. Maybe it was that most of the previous characters wouldn’t be returning. Maybe it was purely out of hope that my extensive letter writing campaign to Disney asking them to UN-make the previous two sequels would yield results. But, much like the time I predicted that Mandy Moore would have a bright future in movies, I stand corrected.

In all honesty, I left Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides a little surprised that it wasn‘t terrible. Wait. Scratch that. “Not terrible” is a bold statement. How about, it wasn’t MORE terrible than any other Pirates flick up until this point, how’s that? In fact, I could even make the case that On Stranger Tides would have made a far more suitable Part 2 in the franchise than it makes a Part 4. But of course, I know that untold billions upon billions of dollars these movies have made worldwide says that there are any number of people that will jump out of the woodwork to disagree with me (I found someone waiting stealthily in my dirty clothes hamper earlier, but they were rendered unconscious) yet still it has to be said that Pirates 2 and 3 SUCKED. ASS. There I said it.

Let’s face it, the whole Davy Jones thing didn’t deserve to be comprised of two back-to-back two and a half hour films, I mean, what happened that was so spectacular that it couldn’t have been told in one film? And it’s just nonsense to do a whole litany of pirate movies and not even so much as mention Blackbeard until Part 4.

But nevertheless, this movie comes AFTER Pirates of the Caribbean 2: Dead Man’s Chest and Pirates of the Caribbean 3: Dead Man’s Chest 2 where all the supernatural stuff, up to and including Capt. Jack Sparrow and Davy Jones fighting on a ship’s mast as it gets sucked into a vortex, has happened and there’s not much you can do to top it. By comparison, that leaves a movie named On Stranger Tides a lot more room to be stranger than probably desired.

If you haven’t seen the movie, you’ve probably heard at least one person say that it’s pretty much more of the same. And that’s an accurate statement. But is that really so bad? I think it depends on how you feel about Pirates of the Caribbean up to this point. If you’ve been a stark raving fan throughout, then more of the same is probably a lot better than something completely off the wall. Otherwise, if you’re like me and think Pirates became a colossal waste of time ten minutes into watching Dead Man’s Chest, then it would be foolhardy to walk into this movie expecting anything OTHER than more of the same. Personally, I’m just happy the movie wasn’t worse than its predecessors, realistically that was the most I or anybody else could really ask for if we’re still volunteering to pay money to see it.

Now, if you thought that this movie would focus more on Capt. Jack Sparrow what with Will Turner and Elizabeth being out of the picture, you thought wrong. He pretty much stands around and does nothing as usual, only to burst out of his shell once or twice before going back to standing around doing nothing as usual. Thankfully, Ian McShane doesn’t disappoint as Blackbeard, and neither does Geoffrey Rush, reprising his role as Capt. Barbosa with typical gusto. I think they were the real stars of the movie.

It’s always right when they cast Penelope Cruz to play the part of Penelope Cruz, because I can scarcely think of any other actress that’s as dead a ringer for Penelope Cruz as herself, Penelope Cruz. Though I don’t know how well she plays a pirate. Not to mention, she comes into this movie in the most predictable fashion ever. Yeah, she should probably stick to playing Penelope Cruz.

But all in all, I don’t think the movie deserves a bad wrap for being another Pirates of the Caribbean movie, after all, that’s exactly what it is and was supposed to be, demanding anything else would be like demanding a better movie out of the next Police Academy (if there should ever be such a thing).

If you are going to see it, you better get in now since, you know, they’re calling for the Apocalypse at some point today. And remember to stay until after the credits for the additional scene (but don’t get your hopes up for anything all that telling, it’s just a quickie). And now, I would now like to use my last moments on Earth to say… I USED TO WATCH SHE-RA AND STILL DO! I REGRET NOTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!